Pros and Cons of Writing Fantasy

Fantasy is a genre of fiction that can be identified by the imaginary, and often bizarre,

elements that constitute the main plot or theme. The setting of fantasy may be an imaginative

fantasy world that can never be true, or a real, historical or future world that has a certain

realistic feel and where fantastic elements may be regarded as alien, unusual, or heterodox

and dangerous. Though the former is long-established, the latter has gained enormous ground

from the popularity of Hollywood blockbusters and video games that are based on both

fantasy and science fiction, the most famous examples of which are the Star War and X-Men

franchises. Another popular strand of fantasy is magical realism, typified by books such as

Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell.

As the author of Children of Swan, which includes both fantasy and scientific fiction

elements, I tend to perceive fantasy as a creative device that can be added to a chosen genre

rather than a rigid, standalone format. Like everything else, writing fantasy, whether a

straight fantasy fiction or an element that is added to a fiction of mixed genres, it has

advantages and disadvantages:

Pros:

Freedom: Fantasy elements can be introduced into an otherwise rather realistic world,

like opening another door, or venturing out into a new territory. It provides a whole

new dimension to exploit.

Opportunity: Don’t just use the fantasy device to satisfy the requirements of the plot.

Regard it as an opportunity to create tension and conflict, and as a way to push the

story forward from a new angle.

The Appeal: We’ve grown up with fables and fairy tales, and fantasy is a way of

escaping our daily, humdrum existence. In our thoughts and our dreams, we are never

far away from a fantasy world. All in all, we have a tendency to be drawn by ideas of

fantasy. Think how much Star Wars is loved. Would it still be loved so much if it

were deprived of the common motifs of fantasy?

 The Joy of Writing it. Like adding cream to a chocolate cake, it is enjoyable.

Cons:

 Inconsistency: Fantasy elements must be internally coherent. When we marry

fantasy to another genre, such as science fiction or history, sometimes it is hard to

keep it convincing in the context of the other genre. For example, making a real-life

bio-scientist easily believe in fairies would raise issues of implausibility and

inconsistency.

 Extra effort: Why do X-men have such superhuman abilities? Where does the Force

in Star Wars come from? Such questions require effort and serious treatment to

make fantasy elements sound plausible and convincing.

 Quagmire: Failing to achieve a convincing marriage that blends fantasy to another

genre will inevitably weaken the story. A good story can be easily spoiled by a

fantasy element that goes wrong, and sink into a hopeless quagmire.

 The despair if you fall into a quagmire. Well, what can I say? We were warned.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Pros and Cons of Writing Fantasy

  1. Thanks for offering a few thoughts on what to consider. Have you read or researched Sanderson’s Laws of Magic? There’s a bit of overlap there you might be interested in reading about them.

    Like

  2. This post is incredibly crucial and pretty smart. I think that fantasy is a really touchy genre (unlike many others) and not any writer can create an original and compelling story with a fantastical world that a reader can easily immerse themselves into and get gripped by.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s